Are we paying more for less?

[JaydedOne]

Mltdwn said:
OK answer me this, what features and abilities does Dom3 add that M2TW doesn't? I'm trying to compare the two and decide which I should invest my money into because other than the "magic" aspect I really can't see what Dom3 brings to the table that is different or better... From what I understand the diplomatic functioning is much more limited due to being primarily a go to war with everyone game, the politics aspect is largely non-existant due to the nature of the game (as opposed to having to deal with the Church, the various other nobles, Crusades, Jihads, Briberies, assassinations, etc.), and the combat is largely more of simply choose the right groups and outnumber the enemies hoping for good enough "rolls" rather than being able to use actual tactics like flanking, luring, ambushes, etc.

Basically what makes Dom3 "better" in terms of features and gameplay?

Let's set aside for a moment that all of the tactics you mention are present in the game, albeit not always as a simple button that you press. We're not here to convince you that Dom3 is a "better" game. As I said, it's apples and oranges and I'd laugh off anyone who tried to sell me Civilization on the premise that it was a "better" game than Dominions.

Play the demo. See if you think it's worth the price. If it is, I'll play a game with you and talk it over here. If not, then perhaps you'll have better luck with M2.

Cheers either way.

[Archonsod]

I don't think there is a game similar to Dominions. The only thing I can see MTW and Dom3 having in common is the fact that you spend your turn moving on the strategy map, then have a battle at the end of it. But then, the same thing can be said of Rise of Nations or Cossacks 2, and both are radically different from total war.

One thing to consider though - since Shrapnel are unlikely to lower the price, it makes sense to get Dom3 now. Not only is MTWII likely to be half price in the January sales, but your likely to be able to pick it up with the inevitable expansion for less than you'll pay on day of release.