Finnish OOB35 Corrections and Suggestions PART 2 -- Units

[Pibwl]

Originally Posted by PvtJoker

In any case, 49 is probably correct, although I wonder if radio-equipped vehicles carried less rounds and that's the reason for varying numbers.

Rather not - there's no mention in Russian sources, and BA-10 carried ammunition at the rear, while radio in front.

Continuing artillery:
- all names should be in fact in "H/37" format rather, than H 37.

- 91 152mm H 37 Bty - captured during a Continuation War, so 6/41 would be probably to early to start - maybe a month or two later.
In fact, they were used by heavy artillery battalions, so they might be classified as heavy arty

- 130 114mm H/1 FH - name should be H/18. Better icon is 2122 (short barrel)

- 131 76mm K 02 FG - better icon is 2111, proposed before for the same unit 78 (it has true narrow trail)

- 132 122mm H 09 FH -better icon is 2115, proposed before for units 80,81 (it had much shorter barrel)

- 149 76mm M27 FG - better icon is short-barrel 2109. It wasn't FG, but IG.

- 152, 158 76mm K36 FG - it should have icon with longer barrel and split trail, eg 57. I'm not sure, if class Infantry Howitzer is proper.

- 153 105mm H33 FG (leFH.18) - better icon is eg. 2105, with split trail (btw. German unit 132 should have the same icon - now it has way too long barrel). I'm not sure, if class Infantry Howitzer for this field howitzer is proper.
It might be available also as Light Off-map Bty, though we have more popular 105 H/37 with yet better performance. Date 5/44 seems OK.

- Unit 154 105mm K29 FG obviously wasn't Class 154 infantry howitzer, but a long-range canon, used from 10/40 (http://www.jaegerplatoon.net/ARTILLERY4.htm). A single gun should be replaced with a battery, presumably of class 10? (in fact it was used in heavy arty units)

- Unit 155 155mm How Bty - it seems, that it should be class 10 Off-map arty, not Off-map Heavy arty - it's ordinary H/17 (mle 17) Schneider howitzer (its name should be changed to H/17 in a pattern of other units). According to Jaeger Platoon, it was most numerous heavy howitzer in Finland. Correct picture should be 23075 or 30290.

Heavy arty unit, with this picture, might be in fact 155mm K/17 Schneider gun (http://www.jaegerplatoon.net/ARTILLERY4.htm), with range 17 km - but only 12 guns were used in 1942 - 6/44, so it is IMO redundant, since there were more popular Soviet 152mm ML-20 with the same performance.


- very welcome addition to off-map arty would be 120mm K/78 or K/78-31, mentioned in Finnish Weapons thread. Similar picture to K/78 is 23230. In fact, used in heavy artillery units.

- there might be added Heavy artillery 21cm H/17 - German Lange Morser unit 328. With a range 10 km, a handful of these guns were used from 4/41 http://www.jaegerplatoon.net/ARTILLERY7.htm

Michal

[PvtJoker]

Originally Posted by Pibwl

Continuing artillery:
- all names should be in fact in "H/37" format rather, than H 37.

- 91 152mm H 37 Bty - captured during a Continuation War, so 6/41 would be probably to early to start - maybe a month or two later.
In fact, they were used by heavy artillery battalions, so they might be classified as heavy arty

- 152, 158 76mm K36 FG - it should have icon with longer barrel and split trail, eg 57. I'm not sure, if class Infantry Howitzer is proper.

- 153 105mm H33 FG (leFH.18) - better icon is eg. 2105, with split trail (btw. German unit 132 should have the same icon - now it has way too long barrel). I'm not sure, if class Infantry Howitzer for this field howitzer is proper.
It might be available also as Light Off-map Bty, though we have more popular 105 H/37 with yet better performance. Date 5/44 seems OK.

- Unit 154 105mm K29 FG obviously wasn't Class 154 infantry howitzer, but a long-range canon, used from 10/40 (http://www.jaegerplatoon.net/ARTILLERY4.htm). A single gun should be replaced with a battery, presumably of class 10? (in fact it was used in heavy arty units)

- Unit 155 155mm How Bty - it seems, that it should be class 10 Off-map arty, not Off-map Heavy arty - it's ordinary H/17 (mle 17) Schneider howitzer (its name should be changed to H/17 in a pattern of other units). According to Jaeger Platoon, it was most numerous heavy howitzer in Finland. Correct picture should be 23075 or 30290.
Michal

It is true that by WW2 naming conventions type designator (H or K) should be followed by / (slash) and the year. However, towards modern times that was changed so that the slash was dropped and replaced by a space:

http://www.puolustusvoimat.fi/portal...8fce00c6621582

I am not sure when this change was officially implemented, but the core of the matter is that it's a very minor point of nomenclature.

As for the "heavy/light" artillery question: By Finnish standards light guns (< 100mm) and light howitzers (< 130mm) were divisional artillery and considered "light". Heavy guns (100-155mm) and heavy howitzers (130-155) mm were typically part of independent artillery units (Finnish army did not have organic artillery at corps or army level) and considered "heavy". Anything bigger than 155mm was super-heavy (järeä in Finnish) artillery regardless of type (gun, howitzer or siege mortar).

So, 155mm howitzers should definitely be in the heavy class, but in any case the different unit classes are there just to enable making reasonable formations for the players -- like Andy said earlier, they do not have to follow historical TO&E slavishly. This also applies to the Infantry Howitzer question, although I agree that anything with a significantly more the 10 km range probably should not be in that unit class (this applies to other OOBs as well).

[Pibwl]

28 Medium Truck - picture is inadequate GMC CCKW. Better is eg. 20512, 22160,

33 Light Truck AOP - picture is inadequate 6x6 Dodge. Better is eg. 22161

44 75mm M40 AT-Gun - they were delivered on 23.5.43 (http://www.jaegerplatoon.net/AT_GUNS2.htm), so they probably should start since 6/43 only (now 5/43)

109, 159 T-38 - picture is T-37 (I'll attach a proposal)
I don't know what is the second entry - differing in front armour 2 and FC=1, available from the same date. I don't know about screened T-38.

138 150mm H 40 Bty- - they arrived only in 10/40 (now 1/40), so this unit, ending in 12/40, can be deleted (there is next unit 89)

By the way: what is a difference between guns and guns with "-"?... I'd understand if they differed in radio, or had additional AP ammo.
131 76mm K 02 FG- is identical as 78, only available earlier - and there is a gap between 9/40-12/40, in which K/02 sure was available as well.
The same situation is with 85 and 133: 76mm K 02 Bty, and also there's a gap

The same situation with:
- 149 and 156 76mm M27 FG (both should have suggested icon 2109)
- 152 and 158 76mm K36 FG
- 87 and 134 122mm H 09 Bty (these should be changed to something else, as off-map arty, anyway)
- 90 and 144 152mm H 09 Bty

Units 80 and 81 122mm H 09 FH differ in radio at least. Maybe all were going to differ, but it wasn't finished?