The Star Trek Mod - v1.9.7.5 (Oct 07)

[Captain Kwok]

Atrocities said:Great, another die hard trek cannon fan.

I think it was a joke AT.

[Fyron]

Black_Knyght said:
To set the record straight - I NEVER dismissed Oleg's work.

You did dismiss it as Tholian/Trek.

[Black_Knyght]

Uh, you're reaching a bit to call that a dismissal. It isn't a dismissal to say the Oleg's version of the Tholian shipset doesn't resemble the ships seen in the original Star Trek or Enterprise. Sorry, but they just don't.

Oleg's set is very good, and I applaud his efforts and creativity with it. I even use it myself, albeit not as the Tholians however. And I'd like to make it clear I have nothing against either him or his set. I simply do not think they share the same overall resemblence to the various ships of Star Trek as do the other sets developed by AT.

I am not, and will not, dismiss somebody elses efforts or works. No matter how thinly stretched any suggestion to the contrary may be.

[Louist]

Now now, I'm not a die hard star trek fan. But that ep. was on spike the other day and gave me a laugh lol

[Fyron]

Please note the qualifier on that sentence...

[Black_Knyght]

Okay, this has officially gone from a debate, to a difference of opinion, to a disagreement, to ridiculous.

At this point any further debate by either myself or Fyron would just boil down to a pissing match, which is nothing more than a waste of time, space, and energy. Lets put an end to this pointlessness, and simply resolve our viewpoints here as follows:

Fyron votes NO

Black_Knyght votes YES


This is not intended to discourage the voicing of opinions by anyone, just simply an effort on my part to end what has pointlessly become an issue of contention.

[NullAshton]

No, this is where a comment may be interpreted to be something that someone acts strongly about, and that someone overreacts and replies harsly back. I've done it before, I should know...

[Atrocities]

Captain Kwok said:

I think it was a joke AT.

I know, I was being cinical

[Kana]

Imperator Fyron said:
Personally, I think the Tholian set is better than most anything else I have seen about "Tholians".
Like these ugly things:
http://www.sfbnexus.com/Tholian/t-pc-a.jpg
http://www.sfbnexus.com/Tholian/T-CA-M2-A.jpg

I actually like the 'ugly' ones at sfbnexus, but I'm bias toward SFB 'canon' ship types...

[Atrocities]

When it comes to star trek, nothing is really cannon. Just look the lack of consistancy between TOS - TNG - DS9 - Voyager * shudder * - and ENT.

Voyager and ENT really blew any sense of cannon right off the map.