Ahh, NAP arguments. Nothing more enjoyable than a good old fashioned NAP argument.
Here is what things look like from the other side of the front. On turn 14, Ano said that if we took any of Mictlan or Jomon's territory, or any of the independents near them, that our NAP would be automatically canceled. On that same turn I told them that we couldn't agree to those demands and that we were going to attack those provinces. I thought we were at war after that. However, even if you go from Ano's declaration of war, there is still a school of thought which say that 18 - 15 = 3. I am partial to that school of thought.
One thing I will agree with Ano about is that the war is far from over, especially as no one has yet suffered any real casualties. I was actually hoping to meet some resistance at his capital while my PoD still has the bonuses from his own dominion.
Additionally, I would note that I was actually attacked without warning on turn 17 by Gath (breaking the NAP3 we had with his team), so in Karmic terms I believe I am still ahead for this game.