Move Along, Nothing to See Here

Ed Kolis · #1 January 9th, 2004, 03:37 AM

You know, there was once a Star Trek episode where Data reported an explosion with a volume of someething like 4x10^23 decibels... forgetting not only that sound doesn't travel in space, but that decibels are already a logarithmic scale...

Though I suppose it would be possible for a sound that loud to travel through space... remember, space isn't REALLY empty, there's the minute amount of interstellar hydrogen, as well as the constant quantum fluctuations of matter and antimatter being created and destroyed out of nothingness... so if you hit a molecule of hydrogen REALLY hard and it shot over a few kilometers and hit the next molecule of hydrogen, which just happened to hit another molecule of hydrogen, I guess you could call that a "sound wave"

Actually, I suppose a sound of any volume would travel through space, because there's no friction to stop the hydrogen molecules from moving until they hit something... the sound would just travel VERY slowly!

Fyron · #2 January 9th, 2004, 03:40 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Graeme Dice:
I believe we need a humour injection, stat!

I don't. A good way to carry out a joke is to act as if it isn't a joke...

Kristoffer O · #3 January 9th, 2004, 07:24 AM

Of course there is noice in the universe! God has a big band playing harps and horns and stuff. If that isn't noicy nothing is.

He also speaks to some of us

Saber Cherry · #4 January 9th, 2004, 07:45 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Kristoffer O:
Of course there is noice in the universe! God has a big band playing harps and horns and stuff. If that isn't noicy nothing is.

He also speaks to some of us

...can you give me some idea of his blessing effects? I wanna know if become sacred is worth the trouble

PvK · #5 January 9th, 2004, 09:01 AM

The "no sound in space" argument seems a bit silly to me in many cases. Where there are living humanoids, they tend to have air around them, so they will hear when their ship gets hit, etc. It seems quite reasonable artistic license for sci-fi film-makers to be able to place microphones all over the scene - even contact microphones on torpedoes, etc.

That Data example is hilarious. TNG bleh...

PvK

General Tacticus · #6 January 9th, 2004, 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Ed Kolis:
You know, there was once a Star Trek episode where Data reported an explosion with a volume of someething like 4x10^23 decibels... forgetting not only that sound doesn't travel in space, but that decibels are already a logarithmic scale...

Though I suppose it would be possible for a sound that loud to travel through space... remember, space isn't REALLY empty, there's the minute amount of interstellar hydrogen, as well as the constant quantum fluctuations of matter and antimatter being created and destroyed out of nothingness... so if you hit a molecule of hydrogen REALLY hard and it shot over a few kilometers and hit the next molecule of hydrogen, which just happened to hit another molecule of hydrogen, I guess you could call that a "sound wave"

Actually, I suppose a sound of any volume would travel through space, because there's no friction to stop the hydrogen molecules from moving until they hit something... the sound would just travel VERY slowly!

Well, I for one believe that a sound that strong would not just send hydrogen atoms colliding with each others, it would ignite a nuclear fusion with each collision. Wait, forget it, it would start a matter to energy direct transformation !! And do BAAD things to any galaxy that happened to be nearby !!

[ January 09, 2004, 08:17: Message edited by: General Tacticus ]