Hell sword vs Wraith sword vs Blood thorn

[En Forcer]

Molog, thanks for clearing that up for me. So given a choice I guess I have to decide between scuttatas and charcoal shields. I suppose the nature of my foe would decide that. Unless you fellows see something in the stats that makes the choice a no-brainer?

[quantum_mechani]

In general, the fire shield is better, as it can damage many more units a turn. Another contender is the Vine Shield.