Opinions Sought and Needed (New Ship Set)

[Shyrka]

Hello Atrocities :-) Here are my comments (Starting with the first ship)

• Very good for a medium craft. But i thik the wings seem too fragile to support these big cannons.
• The best ship. Really good. Seems though and technologist. I like it vey much.
• Very original, but i think that the hexagonal shape makes the ship vulnerable to side attacks. Better design for transports IMO
• Same as above
• I don't like this design. Rare proportion size/cannons. The shape of the ship seems appropiate for a huge one, with much smaller weapons.

In general, i think it some kind of symbol painted in the ships will make them seem better. But i like this first ships. I think you can do an excellent new shipset. What about the race?

[Torkle]

Very nice work! I like all of them except the Last (which looks too much like a sea-going battleship instead of a space vehicle). The 1st, 3rd, and 4th are especially nice and are very distinct in the smaller, overhead view.

[ZeroAdunn]

I really like them. Doga right? They all look nice, especially the Last one. I kinda like the fell of boats in space.

[chewy027]

uh oh looks like we got another doga user ships look great. Only thing I would say is that if they are all part of one fleet then make the transition between ships look better. I realize this isn't all the ships and there probably not in any order, but jusy keep that in mind when you render up the next batch

[Val]

The set looks really good. I particularly liked ship #2.

It looks like the images of 4 & 5 should be swapped to better match the overhead views though.

6 Looks like a carrier of some sort and kind of reminds me of the old 'Starblazers' cartoon.

[Puke]

very good. since 4 is a larger 3, it should probably fill up more of the window. i like them all though, the red stripe at the base of 5 is what contributes most to that 'naval boat' sort of look.

[Tampa_Gamer]

Nice Atrocities, very nice. Try and get them done by December 15th so that we can include them on the Gold CD.

[ 07 December 2001: Message edited by: Tampa_Gamer ]