OT-favorite movie lines

[Gandalf Parker]

NTJedi said:

Nations created from the Hellboy2 movie, Narnia movies, and others would probably be quiet popular especially for SP gamers. Some of these may have modders worried about intellectual property rights, yet I've heard as long as no money or advertising is being made from these creations there's no worry. I also heard it could cause a concern for shrapnelgames, otherwise I would be working on a Sauron nation mod.... who wouldn't want to take an army and fight that eyeball at his capital OR battle the witch king!

Yes there is a problem with it exactly as you said it. The idea of "no problem" usually refers to "they wont come after you" which is different than "its legal and OK to do it". For us as individuals on some unaffiliated forum, it would probably be no problem. But Shrapnel, as a corporation, as a game company, cannot appear to turn a blind eye to blatant copyright infringements. To clearly say that your mod took images and material directly from some other game or book etc etc means that Shrapnel would have to remove it.

On the other hand, this often comes up on other forums I moderate. Particularly with things like fan-based tshirts or posters. One thing I always bring up is "you might try just asking". It doesnt work every time but about 50% of the time I find that there is some way to get permission. And no, it doesnt always involve paying lots of bucks. Sometimes its just asking, and signing a form that says you arent making money on it.