Is password guessing cheating?

[StarJack]

Of course it's cheating! I certainly wouldn't want to waste my time in any game with some chump that felt they had to cheat to compete...

[disabled]

It's still cheating to guess a password, even for the hell of it.

Things that expose cheaters that guess passwords

- Suddenly all thier ships move to another area with no reason
- If they are egotistical, they drop hints to thier own superiority (thus proving hwo dumb they are).
- They know stuff that can be gathered via cloaked ships -- but they don't have cloaking researched.....
- Suddenly they know where all your best shipyards are and destroy them.

Those are just some of the cheaters' ways.

[DavidG]

Originally posted by Hadrian Tyrael S. Aventine:
Things that expose cheaters that guess passwords

- Suddenly all thier ships move to another area with no reason
- If they are egotistical, they drop hints to thier own superiority (thus proving hwo dumb they are).
- They know stuff that can be gathered via cloaked ships -- but they don't have cloaking researched.....
- Suddenly they know where all your best shipyards are and destroy them.

Here One I experienced from a later proven cheater. Their fleets attack all your planets except the one with the massive defenses which they mysteriously avoid.

[geoschmo]

Originally posted by Hadrian Tyrael S. Aventine:
It's still cheating to guess a password, even for the hell of it.

Things that expose cheaters that guess passwords

- Suddenly all thier ships move to another area with no reason
- If they are egotistical, they drop hints to thier own superiority (thus proving hwo dumb they are).
- They know stuff that can be gathered via cloaked ships -- but they don't have cloaking researched.....
- Suddenly they know where all your best shipyards are and destroy them.

Those are just some of the cheaters' ways.

Guessing passwords is cheating, yes, yes, a thousand times yes.

No, it's not even remotly equatable to the intel ops of WWII, or even to any hypothetical Nazi brain reading technology that was or wasn't developed. But all that was during a war. And this is a game. All is fair in love and war. All is not fair in games.

Even real armies during war games don't allow unrestricted warfare. There are things you do during war that you don't do during games.

All that being said, if any of the things Hadrian and DavidG suggests happen to you during a game, PLEASE don't assume it's the work of cheaters. All of these things can just as easily be explained through perfectly legitimate game reasons.

Intelligence, Partnerships with empires that have cloaking technology, even just guessing or raw chance. During a war I will often avoid larger planets, or medium sized planets that are atmosphere correct. I will always check the population of a planet before attacking and make an educated guess about the defensive levels. You can also make supositions based on resource levels. Higher ones would tend to be colonized earlier, thus be older and have more defenses.

Cheating is cheating, but let's not let suspicion and paranoia ruin games either.

Geoschmo

[ June 30, 2002, 21:05: Message edited by: geoschmo ]

[disabled]

That's very true.

The only true way to expose a cheater is to cheat yourself and that is something I doubt anyone wants to see.

I think cheating needs to be handled on a case-by-case system with everything properly investigated and explained.

[DavidG]

Originally posted by geoschmo:
All that being said, if any of the things Hadrian and DavidG suggests happen to you during a game, PLEASE don't assume it's the work of cheaters.

Geoschmo

Double ditto to that. I hope I didn't imply you should assume someone is cheating whenever something happens you can't explain. There are so many ways to get ahead in this game that if you find someone way ahead of you chances are he/she just know something you don't, or got a lucky break etc etc etc

[Hank]

If this ever became a real problem, the game would have to be made more secure by making separate turn results for each player. A player's turn result would only contain data for his/her race. PBW would only allow downloading of a player's turn result thru their login.

Edit: Forgot to mention. Cheaters Suck Hind Tit!

[ July 01, 2002, 23:48: Message edited by: Hank ]