MP Game: How bad is too bad?

[WingedDog]

Originally Posted by Sombre

Had Player A not left, should he have been subbed anyway for his very poor performance?

Player skill should be specified by administrator of the game in the OP of the game. Administrator also should make a selection of players joined. If administrator didn't do all this before game had started then it is unethical to kick someone from the game.
And if player X is pissed off by someone's poor performance in the game - he just should stop joining all are welcome type of games.
I believe people from IRC know each other pretty well and could start a closed invite-only game.