The best PD ?

[Executor]

I'd say monkey PD is better than Jotun PD. The high HP doesn't count for jack when they can't hit anything, and it's not like they can swarm the attacker. At least the monkeys can throw a few rocks and arrows...

Hinnom used to be scary until the nerf. EA Abysian probably has the best PD. They have no archers, which is good, since thay can be drawn away with cheap decoys. Very strong units, with high protection for EA, and on top of all a heat aura on all troops, meaning any thug raiding has to be fire resistant, if they can take the PD at all as I've seen numerous thugs, Bane lords and Sleepers, get killed by Abysian PD.

Now, if mod nations count, I'd say Hellgate(Amos) has the most ridiculous PD. :P