Undead retreated?

[Peter Ebbesen]

Originally posted by Argitoth:

quote:

---

Originally posted by Peter Ebbesen:
The easiest way to kill hordes of SG troops in melee is to make them commit suicide.

You might be on to something... but what do you mean by this?

---

Just another reference to the fire shield/regeneration combination. The great weaknesses of SG undead (with the exception of the wailing lady and the leaders, obviously) is that they 1) don't do all that much damage per attack and 2) have few hitpoints. Their strengths are 1) their small size which allows them to mob units, 2) their unconventional attacks which can nullify their opponents physical attacks, and 3) their ethereality which makes them hard to hit.

The fire shield/regeneration combination takes advantage of their weaknesses and nullifies most of their strengths.

It would work even better with a naturally regeneration monster like a troll lord.

[ March 26, 2004, 19:37: Message edited by: Peter Ebbesen ]

[Tuna-Fish]

Originally posted by Argitoth:
You might be on to something... but what do you mean by this?

I think he mean use charcoal shileds that give a fireshield, so the undead will hit your troops and die to the fireshield.

Note that long weapons with magic effect can go just the same thing when wielded by unit that has a lot more attack skill that the attackers.

Flambeau is lenght 3, lighning spear is lenght 4.

[Argitoth]

Bane blade is length 3 and the lords have 14 attack.

CHARCOAL SHIELD
5 Earth, 5 Fire

-5 Protection
-2 Defence
-Fire Shield

[ March 26, 2004, 19:50: Message edited by: Argitoth ]

[ywl]

Originally posted by Taqwus:
Life drain attacks inherent to monsters -- ghosts, vampires, horrors, et al -- are generally melee-only. The life drain spell, on the other hand, has some range. Wielded against undead, neither provides the usual healing and reinvigoration side effect.
Ghosts are not terrifically strong against undead, particularly undead with magical attack forms since the magical weapons ignore etherealness. I'd probably prefer undead archers, for their ability to hit the undead masses before meleeing, and since banefire arrows are conveniently magical; it might be possible to do fire-and-run attacks with them.

I apologize. I've forgotten about their undead status...

Somebody has to check whether the life drain of ghost is effective versus SG undeads. They're undeads but they're not inanimate or lifeless. Most of the weapon of SG require a check versus MR. Ghost's MR is quite high. That will be a plus.

For fodder, it's probably easier to just used "Dispossessed Spirits" that you've already researched. 4 gems for 15 of them. It's a good buy. Since you also get nature, you can crank up the protection of Vine men or Vine Ogres. They're lousy junk. But they're cheap. There is no point fighting mass of undeads with elite troops. It's your priests who will be doing the job any way.

Bane lords are usable but you need some way for him to kill the ethereal undeads in massive number before being overwhelmed. SG's dispossed spirits will be extremely nasty in this case, because after enough hits, they might eventually paralyze your Bane Lords. I think they can even paralyze mindless summons like Winter Wolves - don't ask me why . "Charcoal Shield" might indeed the only economical way.

The battle will be cute as it would be an two almost identical armies of undeads fighting each other .

What I meaned hopeless is more because: if you're down to the Last one or two provinces, his troop production will overwhelm you sooner or later unless somebody else step in and attack him now.

[Argitoth]

Originally posted by ywl:
What I meaned hopeless is more because: if you're down to the Last one or two provinces, his troop production will overwhelm you sooner or later unless somebody else step in and attack him now.

Caelum, Jotunheim, Pythium, I think Man, and soon T'ien Ch'i will be attacking Ermor.

[rabelais]

Originally posted by Argitoth:
Caelum, Jotunheim, Pythium, I think Man, and soon T'ien Ch'i will be attacking Ermor.

This is the most diplomatically inappropriate thing ever posted in a public place.

Ye Gods, but you're an idiot, Argitoth.

Edit: Actually I take this back. It's actually quite clever to sabotage everyone's relations with Ermor, and entirely in your interest to do so.

Its still unspeakably asinine, though. /edit

As for the actual assertion,.. Ermor and I have perfectly peaceful relations, or at least we DID. ;(

I'll thank you not to presume too much from death gem donations for the common good.


Celestial Rabe the Appalled

[ March 26, 2004, 20:48: Message edited by: rabelais ]

[Peter Ebbesen]

Originally posted by Argitoth:

quote:

---

Originally posted by ywl:
What I meaned hopeless is more because: if you're down to the Last one or two provinces, his troop production will overwhelm you sooner or later unless somebody else step in and attack him now.

Caelum, Jotunheim, Pythium, I think Man, and soon T'ien Ch'i will be attacking Ermor.

---

Are you posting other players' plans here? I sure hope you have their consent in revealing them, otherwise it is a diplomatic faux pas of the highest order. Nations have burned for less.

On the other hand, if it is an ingeniously planted piece of misinformation intended to sow dissension between current allies but future enemies, my congratulations.