Re: Fog of war
I must admit justified points, I always thought including men on first screen a bit strange as you tend to notice it. Useful for gun crews & if you were going to be gamey could use to know teams have limited shots.
Its main use for me is looking up vehicle & to a lesser extent gun capabilities you can after all get a good idea of the shape infantry is in from the icon.
As you say maybe an optional thing but has its drawbacks example with infantry.
When I buy my force if dont know other sides capabilities I select them as allies & have a quick look at possible capabilities then buy my force..
With infantry thats AT & ranges of weapons mainly plus if they have a diffrent support squad.
In game have no need to look up infantry just assume the worst esp with AT weapons as most players buy the good ones mainly
So vs the AI (regular turns) no need to look as can remember the support squad as he say fired 2 LMGs so has no AT.
In PBEM if a few days pass then I have forgotten which one he was so might look it up if tactical situation calls for it.
Could I suppose write it down but the game is geared to PBEM with a gap between playing to save you having to do this. Unit leaves your LOS but does not instantly disapear like it would to allow you to comeback & "remember"
This could probably be changed so he vanishes & now some players would resort to pen & paper keeping track of where units went.
Just my view but this would detract from the game though human nature means someone will be bothered to do it.
Having said that though cant see it happening but I would be happy if vehicle info gave detail & troops just said infantry but it occurs to me some players would just get silly.
Look at all troop configurations write them down now watch them fire closely & you can tell what squad type it is or narrow it to a couple max.
In reality this is what you do anyway but to a far smaller extent, hes been firing GL at my squad so has one of 2 RPGs we will err on the side of safety & assume the longer ranged varient, at some time in the game we will probably have to risk it & find out.
The other thing is where do you stop if you really want to open the flood gates for the pen & paper brigade & have fog of war.
Dont show enemy suppressed status is it pinned or in good order, did it rally?
Redo tiles & icons so units become very hard to see in woods smoke (TI hum) even when spotted, then remove P&N buttons for targeting & ID tags etc.
Sorry a bit long winded & thinking about it when I stumble into squads armed with them flame rockets do wish I had looked first.
|