Never mind, think I figured it out myself. You can only see the dominion in a province that is next to a province where you have positive dominion. In this case even though my pretender a temple and prophet were all there, the dominion was exactly 0 that turn. Next turn the dominion went to 2, and then I could see it again. I was confused because the turn before, the province my pretender is in was 1, it went down to 0 due to the highly negative surrounding dominions and temples.
Personally, I'd like to be able to see the dominions in all provinces that are next to provinces where I have positive dominion (as it is now) and also all dominions next to provinces I control (which it apparently is not). It just doesn't make sense to me that I don't know who my next door neighbors are worshipping. I'd also like to be able to see dominion in any province I have a scout, and certainly a scout with priest levels, it only makes sense. Ah well, at least I figured it out. Apparently the final choice, I'm just an idiot, was the correct one!
[ March 29, 2004, 05:36: Message edited by: Minrhael ]